➾ The Civil War as a Theological Crisis Free ➵ Author Mark A. Noll – Moi-sosedi.info

The Civil War as a Theological Crisis Mark Noll s book argues, convincingly, that the civil war can be understood not simply as a constitutional crisis but a theological crisis for American Protestants and really, for Christianity at large in light of the existence of American Protestantism In fact, the constitutional crisis had significant theological roots, and we cannot understand the constitutional crisis in absence of this theological context Given that America was a de facto Protestant nation, with its firm belief in sola Mark Noll s book argues, convincingly, that the civil war can be understood not simply as a constitutional crisis but a theological crisis for American Protestants and really, for Christianity at large in light of the existence of American Protestantism In fact, the constitutional crisis had significant theological roots, and we cannot understand the constitutional crisis in absence of this theological context Given that America was a de facto Protestant nation, with its firm belief in sola scriptura and individual liberty, it was essentially a crisis of Biblical hermeneutics After all, for anyone who bothered to look, it s clear that the Bible does not explicitly condemn slavery If anything, it seems to accept it as a fact of life I think, given that Protestant America is in a similar crisis right now with respect to gay rights, this is essent This book is fantastic I had to slow myself down to consider and process some of the info and analysis It s a short volume but scholarly If you ve haven t read much on the Civil War you probably should read somegeneralized book s on the conflict unless you are only focused on the theological crisis And, this is not a history of religion in the Civil War nor does it focus on one denomination both the Methodist and Baptist church split over the slavery issue leading up to the war The This book is fantastic I had to slow myself down to consider and process some of the info and analysis It s a short volume but scholarly If you ve haven t read much on the Civil War you probably should read somegeneralized book s on the conflict unless you are only focused on the theological crisis And, this is not a history of religion in the Civil War nor does it focus on one denomination both the Methodist and Baptist church split over the slavery issue leading up to the war The scope of analysis is focused on the national scene and the big moral questions of the day Why is this an important subject Author James McPherson author of the American Civil War best This book shows how the beliefs and assumptions held by American Christians in 1860 precluded any kind of critical reflection on the Civil War If you ve read Nathan Hatch s Democratization of American Christianity, this serves as an excellent second installment in the saga Many of the ideals whose development Hatch chronicles played important roles in paving the way for the Civil War ethos This book is also a nice supplement to Harry S Stout s Upon the Altar of the Nation Stout beautifully This book shows how the beliefs and assumptions held by American Christians in 1860 precluded any kind of critical reflection on the Civil War If you ve read Nathan Hatch s Democratization of American Christianity, this serves as an excellent second installment in the saga Many of the ideals whose development Hatch chronicles played important roles in paving the way for the Civil War ethos This book is also a nice I ve gotten into debates with people about whether the Bible allows for slavery Everyone I have ever argued with has argued that the Bible condemns slavery We are unified as Christians in seeing slavery as a horrific sin.Yet go back to the era of the Civil War and the mainstream opinion was that the Bible approved of slavery Mark Noll s fantastic book documents this in great detail He shows that the very ideologies that made America what it was, such as individualism and democracy, led to a I ve gotten into debates with people about whether the Bible allows for slavery Everyone I have ever argued with has argued that the Bible condemns slavery We are unified as Christians in seeing slavery as a horrif Intriguingly even handed Won t just assume that the America of the past wasreligiously faithful, but endeavors to quantify that Won t just assume that the consequences of that fervor and piety are entirely positive bu A fantastic, deep study of religion and society during the turning point in our country s history I m going to have to readbooks by Mark Noll, because he s bringing the intellectual study of Christianity that I ve always craved.I read the book on Sunday mornings, usually sitting outside with a cup of coffee and the chance to think hard about what I was reading One chapter or even just part of one was all I could manage at one time, since there was so much material to turn over in my mind A fantastic, deep study of religion and society during the turning point in our country s history I m going to have to readbooks by Mark Noll, because he s bringing the intellectual study of Christianity that I ve always craved.I read the book on Sunday mornings, usually sitting outside with a cup of coffee and the chance to think hard about what I was reading One chapter or even just part of one was all I could manage at one time, since there was so much material to turn over in my mind About a third of the way through I decided to always have a pencil with me to underline parts and take notes in the margins Some day I may re read this book and will be interested to see what I found most meaningful in 2009 It will also give me a chance to mark up that first This book clarified a number of important things for me in a very readable format Originally a set of lectures, the chapters come across as someone talking to you and the arguments are laid out so that one might be able to follow them orally easily I had always wondered about the Biblical arguments over slavery Pro slavery arguments always seemed able to quote chapter and verse, and I could never seem to find any anti slavery arguments with a similar approach There were some, apparently, but This book clarified a number of important things for me in a very readable format Originally a set of lectures, the chapters come across as someone talking to you and the arguments are laid out so that one might be able to follow them orally easily I had always wondered about the Biblical arguments over slavery Pro slavery arguments always seemed able to quote chapter and verse, and I could never seem to find any anti slavery arguments with a similar approach There were some, a Viewing The Civil War As A Major Turning Point In American Religious Thought, Mark A Noll Examines Writings About Slavery And Race From Americans Both White And Black, Northern And Southern, And Includes Commentary From Protestants And Catholics In Europe And Canada Though The Christians On All Sides Agreed That The Bible Was Authoritative, Their Interpretations Of Slavery In Scripture Led To A Full Blown Theological Crisis. A very interesting book Heart breaking many times Quite a bit of coverage to main stream Protestants andconservative Catholics would have liked to have seen a littleabout Lutherans, which I think might have also been helpful It is clear that the American Civil War generated a first order theological crisis over how to interpret the Bible, how to understand the work of God in the world, and how to exercise the authority of theology in a democratic society The theological crisi A very interesting book Heart breaking many times Quite a bit of coverage to main stream Protestants andconservative Catholics would have liked to have seen a littleabout Lutherans, which I think might have also been helpful It is clear that the American Civil War generated a first order theological crisis over how to interpret the Bible, how to understand the work of God in the world, and how to exercise the authority of theology in a democratic society The theological crisis of the Civil War was that while voluntary reliance on the Bible had contributed greatly to the creation of American national culture, that s Recommended here.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *